Ernst Law Group and Trial Lawyers for Justice Attorneys Named CAOC's 2026 Consumer Attorneys of the Year for $63M Chevron Verdict
PR Newswire
SAN LUIS OBISPO, Calif., Nov. 16, 2026
SAN LUIS OBISPO, Calif., Nov. 16, 2026 /PRNewswire/ -- Eight attorneys with Ernst Law Group APC and Trial Lawyers for Justice have been named the 2026 Consumer Attorneys of the Year by Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) for their work representing a man who developed cancer years after living in a home built over a buried oilfield waste pit.
Taylor Ernst, Don A. Ernst, Danielle E. Miller, Terry J. Kilpatrick, Jakob Z. Norman, Erin Powers, Ansley O'Brian and Brian J. Ward received the honor for their work in Wright, et al. v. Union Oil Company of California, a toxic tort case that resulted in a $63 million jury award, including $41 million in punitive damages, against Chevron. Union Oil later became part of Chevron.
The case began when Taylor Ernst received an unexpected phone call. The caller was a former Santa Maria resident who had been diagnosed with multiple myeloma, a type of blood cancer, and wanted to know whether there was any connection to the home where he had lived decades earlier.
"He said, 'I got cancer. I live in Las Vegas,'" Ernst recalled. "I asked him, 'Why are you calling lawyers in California?' He told me he used to live in Santa Maria, and his son had driven by the old neighborhood. Their house wasn't there anymore."
What followed was an extensive investigation into a property that had long since disappeared. The legal team spent months reconstructing the site's history through historical records, aerial photographs, and expert analysis. Their work uncovered a buried oilfield sump pit beneath the former home, an area where oilfield waste had been deposited and later covered. The team developed evidence that benzene from the pit had migrated through the soil and into the home, exposing Wright to a chemical associated with his cancer.
The discovery linked a family's former home to an industrial operation hidden from the homeowners who later purchased the property.
Proving that connection was far from straightforward. Wright had lived in the home for only about two years, and his diagnosis came many years later. The defense mounted an extensive challenge, with 10 attorneys in the courtroom and additional lawyers working behind the scenes. The case involved five Evidence Code section 402 hearings, each presenting a potentially case-ending hurdle for the plaintiffs.
"There was a moment in this case when I remember putting my head in my hands and thinking, 'I don't know how we're going to do this,'" Ernst said.
The defense made a $50,000 settlement offer, but the team chose to take the case to trial. There was no mediation and no extended negotiation.
"This was war," Ernst said.
The trial lasted 23 days and culminated in a jury finding Chevron 100% responsible for Wright's injuries. The jury awarded $22 million in compensatory damages and $41 million in punitive damages. It also found that Wright's claim was not barred by the statute of limitations because he had no reason to suspect that his cancer was connected to a home he had left decades earlier.
The case had an impact beyond the courtroom. It shows that dangerous chemicals like benzene left in the ground create liability for polluters, even years and decades later. The litigation ultimately resolved in 2025 through a confidential settlement and dismissal. Wright did not live to see the case fully concluded.
He said the case came down to a choice that every trial lawyer eventually faces: whether to pursue the result a client deserves or give in to the pressure that comes with a difficult fight.
"There are moments in your career you get to decide between becoming the lawyer you want to become or giving in to the emotional pressure that's always going to be there," Ernst said. "And with the team that we had on this one, it wasn't a choice. We had to do the right thing."
The Consumer Attorney of the Year Award is one of CAOC's highest honors, recognizing attorneys whose work reflects the organization's commitment to protecting consumers and holding wrongdoers accountable. The 2026 award recognizes the eight attorneys' work in a case that required years of investigation, complex scientific and historical evidence, and a willingness to take on a major corporation at trial.
About Ernst Law Group APC
Ernst Law Group APC is a California trial law firm based in San Luis Obispo that focuses on traumatic brain injury litigation and has released the Ernst Way: A Definitive Guide to Brain Injury Litigation in March of 2026. While the firm focuses on TBI cases, they are interested in representing individuals and families in any case that needs a trial firm.
About Trial Lawyers for Justice
Trial Lawyers for Justice represents individuals and families in complex litigation and catastrophic injury matters, focusing on holding corporations and other powerful entities accountable for harm caused by their conduct.
View original content to download multimedia:https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ernst-law-group-and-trial-lawyers-for-justice-attorneys-named-caocs-2026-consumer-attorneys-of-the-year-for-63m-chevron-verdict-302941153.html
SOURCE Ernst Law Group

